Choosing For Yourself
John Stuart Mill’s On Liberty, Chapter 3

Table of Contents

Picture of <b>Adam Gjesdal</b><br><small>PhD in Philosophy, University of Arizona</small>
Adam Gjesdal
PhD in Philosophy, University of Arizona

Warm-Up: Should You Live Like Your Grandparents?

Imagine if your career, your romantic partner, your weekend plans, and even your religious views had all been chosen for you by past generations – that you were expected to live essentially the life your grandparents lived, only in a new decade. Some people find comfort in having their lives largely plotted out for them. Most of us, though, rebel at the thought. The kind of life that made your parents and grandparents happy may be entirely unsuited to you. For you to build a life in which you can flourish, you need both the freedom to choose and a real range of options.

Much social progress is a matter of overcoming artificial barriers that narrow those options. Until well into the twentieth century, many elite universities refused to admit women. Supporting this barrier was a patriarchal value system that saw women as unfit to pursue positions of power and prestige, and thus having no need for higher education. Much of society — men and women alike — internalized this view, treating attempts to undermine it as morally wrong. This is a common pattern. When people try to expand their freedom, they face obstacles, both from institutions resistant to change and the moral disapproval of their friends, family, and neighbors.

Resisting that disapproval takes real courage, self-assuredness, and perseverance. Early social reformers, such as the first feminists to attend university, faced significant opposition. Despite these obstacles, they successfully blazed a new path for others to follow. In this reading, we’ll consider John Stuart Mill’s argument that such people are “the salt of the earth,” and that free societies depend on them to remain technologically, economically, and culturally vibrant and dynamic.

Introduction

John Stuart Mill (1806–1873) was an English philosopher and one of the most influential political thinkers of the nineteenth century. He was educated at home by his father James Mill in a famously rigorous program of classical and philosophical study, reportedly reading ancient Greek by the age of three. The elder Mill was a close associate of Jeremy Bentham, and the younger Mill was raised to embrace the utilitarian movement Bentham founded. For most of his adult life, Mill worked as an administrator at the East India Company, then served briefly as a Member of Parliament in the 1860s. He made important contributions to logic, political economy, and the cause of women’s enfranchisement, the last of which he pursued together with his wife, Harriet Taylor Mill. She also made significant intellectual contributions to On Liberty, and some scholars argue she should be regarded as the work’s co-author. John Stuart Mill’s most widely read works today are Utilitarianism (1861) and On Liberty (1859).

On Liberty is centrally concerned with the justified limits of power over individuals. The book famously defends the “harm principle,” which holds that we are justified in interfering with another person’s liberty only to prevent harm to others. This principle is anti-paternalistic, rejecting as illegitimate any attempt to limit a person’s freedom for their own good. In Chapter 3, which we discuss below, Mill argues that societies benefit from allowing people to live in unconventional ways. These attempts at living differently are what he calls “experiments in living,” and Mill thinks they are instructive to the rest of us regardless of whether they fail or succeed in revealing new ways of flourishing. A society full of such experimenters, he thinks, is more dynamic and vigorous than one whose members all live in essentially the same way. The full text of On Liberty is available here.

Connection

The Harm Principle

The harm principle is Mill’s answer to a fundamental question: when may society interfere with what an individual does? His answer: only to prevent harm to others. If your conduct affects only yourself, society has no right to stop you. 

When you get drunk in your own home, that choice concerns you alone. Driving drunk is a different matter. When you drive impaired, your conduct threatens others, and society may use coercion, such as threats of fines or jail, to stop you.

One important clarification: the harm principle applies only to adults capable of freely and rationally deciding for themselves, or of choosing autonomously. Children have not developed that capacity, which is why restricting alcohol sales to minors is consistent with Mill’s framework, even though restricting adult drinking (assuming no threat of harm to others) is not.

Learn more about Mill’s harm principle from this short video produced by BBC Radio 4 and narrated by Harry Shearer.

Key Concepts

Experiment in Living – A new way of living that isn’t yet socially accepted. Just as scientific experiments provide evidence that a specific hypothesis is true or false, experiments in living provide evidence that some novel kind of activity does or does not contribute to human happiness. The idea is very broad, covering ways of arranging society as well as ways of arranging an individual’s life, including one’s romantic life, career, or leisure activities. Establishing a socialist commune, raising a family as a gay couple, or being one of the first women to attend university are all examples.

Genius – An individual with a great deal of imagination and the motivation to act on it. For Mill, genius is not limited to scientific or artistic genius; it also extends to the kind of person who imagines genuinely new ways of doing things that are not socially accepted. In doing so, they engage in an experiment in living. Importantly, this genius does not force their way of life onto others: they respect others’ freedom to live as they choose. So, Mill’s defense of genius would not apply to violent political revolutionaries.

Eccentricity – A trait closely related to genius: a disregard for social conventions and the pressures for social conformity. People may be legally free to engage in experiments in living in the sense that no laws prohibit them. Yet external pressures to meet social expectations, along with internal desires to conform, may prevent them from doing so. Experiments in living thus require people who combine genius with eccentricity.

You Do You

Mill believes that a good life can look different depending on the individual. People vary in their interests, talents, and tastes, and forcing someone to act contrary to these makes them miserable. Much of this variation comes from genetics or early life experience. But even identical twins can diverge, shaped by small differences in their experiences as they grow older. The best life for one may be quiet contemplation as a university academic, while the other thrives as a frenzied corporate executive, constantly managing relationships and crises. Were these siblings to swap adult lives, they would find themselves living in hell.

Chapter 3, page 270

The same things which are helps to one person towards the cultivation of his higher nature, are hindrances to another. The same mode of life is a healthy excitement to one, keeping all his faculties of action and enjoyment in their best order, while to another it is a distracting burthen, which suspends or crushes all internal life. Such are the differences among human beings in their sources of pleasure, their susceptibilities of pain, and the operation on them of different physical and moral agencies, that unless there is a corresponding diversity in their modes of life, they neither obtain their fair share of happiness, nor grow up to the mental, moral, and aesthetic stature of which their nature is capable. Why then should tolerance, as far as the public sentiment is concerned, extend only to tastes and modes of life which extort acquiescence by the multitude of their adherents?

Sometimes, a child’s aptitudes point towards a certain kind of established profession that parents and neighbors recognize as respectable. Other times, a person’s tastes put them at odds with every conventional path. Mill worries that public toleration only extends to the first sort of person. But if we care about the individual’s happiness, we should approve of their search for the life that best suits them, even if that involves turning their back on tested, socially accepted paths.

Connection

Does Capitalism Reward Experiments?

What form of society best allows for this kind of experimentation? Mill does not take up this question in Chapter 3. What follows applies his idea rather than reporting his own claims. 

So far, we’ve focused on careers as experiments in living. Capitalism rewards this kind of experimentation. If you spot an unmet demand and think you can meet it, you are free to start a business. And if your product succeeds, you may grow rich. The capitalist system rewards people carving out new paths for themselves, at least when that involves buying and selling goods and services in a marketplace.

But experiments in living extend beyond our work lives. They include new practices of religion or spirituality, new forms of artistic expression, and other goods that are not of the right kind to be offered in a market. Capitalism encourages one kind of experimentation, but in directing our attention and energy toward market activity, it may discourage others. Mill’s defense of experiments in living is not obviously a defense of free market capitalism. Capitalism may even promote public disapproval of experiments that do not fit the mold of a market.

Standing on the Shoulders of Giants

Ideas, technologies, and activities we take for granted were all, at one time, novel inventions, imagined by some creative genius. Pythagoras worked out his theorem. Steve Jobs and his team designed the iPhone. Many of these inventors remain unknown. In recent memory, someone was the first livestreamer. A few thousand years ago, after the formation of the earliest cities, someone was the first person to spend their day running a grocery store. Several thousand years earlier, before our hunter-gatherer ancestors established stationary communities, there was the first person to plant crops and try sustainable agriculture.

Once these inventions exist, they become common property for the rest of us to enjoy and copy. But the initial leap takes a unique act of imagination, and the people who make it do us an immense service. A society full of such inventors keeps introducing new ways of living that make people better off. For Mill, they make society dynamic and vibrant. It is because of them that societies make progress, enabling us to live better lives than our grandparents.

Chapter 3, page 267

[T]here are but few persons, in comparison with the whole of mankind, whose experiments, if adopted by others, would be likely to be any improvement on established practice. But these few are the salt of the earth; without them, human life would become a stagnant pool. Not only is it they who introduce good things which did not before exist; it is they who keep the life in those which already existed.

Objection

Trapped in a Failed Experiment

Mill is optimistic about experiments in living. Even when they fail, they teach us something. But this offers little consolation to participants when an experiment goes very badly. They don’t get back the years they spent so the rest of us can learn from their mistakes.

Take adult use of social media. Platforms like YouTube or Facebook open new ways for millions to make a living and find community, which Mill would welcome. But personalized feeds can also wall users off inside echo chambers, where each user meets a version of the world built to confirm what they already believe. Adults who spend years inside one may come to hold a badly distorted picture of reality and to organize their lives around it. These communities produce people who are the opposite of what Mill admires. They think of themselves as independent-minded, when in fact they have sacrificed their judgment for a sense of belonging. Their beliefs are not really attempts to track the truth. Rather, they are markers of identity that distinguish an in-group from an out-group.

When these online groups call for violence, the harm principle gives society room to intervene. But when an adult of sound mind harms no one but themselves, Mill says they should be free to live as they wish. Spending your days commenting on obscure message boards in defense of an absurd conspiracy theory is this kind of conduct. 

Such a person is running an experiment in living, made possible by social media. To outsiders, their experiment looks like a clear failure. The value of leaving them free to continue that experiment lies in the rest of us learning from its failure. Many people are now wary of echo chambers because they have watched someone close become lost inside one. Yet that lesson is little consolation to the ones left behind.

For Mill, the alternative to permitting risky experiments is the stagnation he associates with declining cultures. Experimentation drives social and economic growth. Small improvements built up over time gave us the internet and social media, and made billions better off, with longer, healthier lives and greater freedom to pursue their own vision of the good. These benefits likely dwarf the harms of failed experiments.

Still, the worry lingers. Societies progress through individual lives, and some of those lives are spent paying tuition for everyone else’s education.

The Value of Choosing for Yourself

Mill believes there is a distinctive value in choosing for yourself, regardless of whether you make the right or wrong choice. Imagine the difference between going to medical school because your parents want you to and going because you’ve decided you want to become a doctor. In the former case, you might never consider your other options, your wants and aptitudes, or your long-term contributions to the world. In the latter, you show a level of maturity and discrimination in attending to what shape of life you want.

Chapter 3, pages 262-263

He who lets the world, or his own portion of it, choose his plan of life for him, has no need of any other faculty than the ape-like one of imitation. He who chooses his plan for himself, employs all his faculties. He must use observation to see, reasoning and judgment to foresee, activity to gather materials for decision, discrimination to decide, and when he has decided, firmness and self-control to hold to his deliberate decision. And these qualities he requires and exercises exactly in proportion as the part of his conduct which he determines according to his own judgment and feelings is a large one. It is possible that he might be guided in some good path, and kept out of harm’s way, without any of these things. But what will be his comparative worth as a human being?

It is possible that, even if your parents decide for you, you end up with a rewarding medical career. Yet in deciding for yourself, you manifest a range of virtues that, for Mill, are distinctively human, characterizing the kinds of people society generally admires above those who simply follow directions and imitate others. 

Elsewhere in On Liberty, Mill adds that you are better placed than anyone else to choose what is good for you. As an adult, you know far more about your own tastes, talents, character, and circumstances than anyone else does, even someone who has known you your whole life. So you are more likely to choose well for yourself than anyone else would be in choosing for you.

Thought Experiment

 Let the AI decide?

Mill claims that life is diminished when the choosing is done for us. Imagine a highly reliable AI that assigns each person to the career in which they are most likely to both flourish and contribute to society. The AI makes these judgments based on extensive data about your specific talents and circumstances, contrasting them with other people’s. You plan to become a lawyer; the AI tells you to become a plumber instead. Its track record is excellent. Would you follow its recommendation? What would you gain if you did, and what would you lose? Does Mill give you reason to resist the AI even when it is probably right about you?

Individuality Isn’t Selfishness

So far individuality might sound like it is all about the self. You do what is best for you, and you look to others mainly to find better ways of living your own life. That can look like selfishness, with each person turned inward and indifferent to everyone else.

Mill denies this. He claims that a society of self-cultivators is drawn together by admiration for people who pursue their own course in life.

Chapter 3, page 266

It is not by wearing down into uniformity all that is individual in themselves, but by cultivating it and calling it forth, within the limits imposed by the rights and interests of others, that human beings become a noble and beautiful object of contemplation; and as the works partake the character of those who do them, by the same process human life also becomes rich, diversified, and animating, furnishing more abundant aliment to high thoughts and elevating feelings, and strengthening the tie which binds every individual to the race, by making the race infinitely better worth belonging to.

The selfishness worry assumes that caring about your own development means caring less about others. Mill argues the reverse. Cultivating your own character makes you find more value in others who do the same, and them in you. Part of that value is aesthetic. A person who has made something of herself is a noble and beautiful object of contemplation, in a way that someone who conforms to the common mold is not.

This holds even when someone’s way of life would be entirely wrong for you. You can think their experiment would suit you terribly and still admire the discrimination and self-control behind it. Their self-cultivation is worth contemplating for its own sake, on top of anything it teaches you about your own life. So individuality does not leave you indifferent to others. It gives you more reason to value them, and it makes the community more worth belonging to.

Join My Experiment, or Else!

Mill’s harm principle constrains experiments in living as much as anything else. There is distinctive value in autonomously choosing to do things your own way, but your choices cannot impose harm on people who have not consented to bear it.

Chapter 3, pages 260-261

As it is useful that while mankind are imperfect there should be different opinions, so is it that there should be different experiments of living; that free scope should be given to varieties of character, short of injury to others; and that the worth of different modes of life should be proved practically, when any one thinks fit to try them. It is desirable, in short, that in things which do not primarily concern others, individuality should assert itself. Where, not the person’s own character, but the traditions or customs of other people are the rule of conduct, there is wanting one of the principal ingredients of human happiness, and quite the chief ingredient of individual and social progress.

What counts as “harm” is itself contested, but some things clearly violate the harm principle. Violent political revolutionaries who “experiment” by conscripting a society into their vision fall on the wrong side of the line. In contrast, a voluntary socialist commune, where each participant joins by choice and is free to leave, falls on the correct side. Mill is opposed to aggressive utopianism that makes all of society an experiment, without the free choice of each of its members.

Weirdos and Witch Hunts

People dislike eccentricity, and we tend to moralize that dislike. Someone does things their own way, which makes us feel uncomfortable. Rather than sit with the discomfort, we frame their conduct as not merely unusual but vicious, or perhaps even as threatening to society.

Chapter 3, pages 270-271

But the man, and still more the woman, who can be accused either of doing “what nobody does,” or of not doing “what everybody does,” is the subject of as much depreciatory remark as if he or she had committed some grave moral delinquency. Persons require to possess a title, or some other badge of rank, or of the consideration of people of rank, to be able to indulge somewhat in the luxury of doing as they like without detriment to their estimation. To indulge somewhat, I repeat: for whoever allow themselves much of that indulgence, incur the risk of something worse than disparaging speeches—they are in peril of a commission de lunatico, and of having their property taken from them and given to their relations.

This moralizing tendency makes eccentric people prime targets for coercion. They love the wrong kind of person, or dress in ways that flout convention, or speak out against their social superiors when they should keep to themselves. Societies have treated each of these as grounds for restricting liberty, whether that be through social ostracism or criminal penalties. Mill observes that responses to eccentricity can range from disapproving talk, to a loss of social standing, to being involuntarily committed to a mental institution while having one’s property seized by relatives. We look back on much of past generations’ moralizing as ludicrous. But we share the same psychology, and our current judgments about the people we find odd deserve the same suspicion.

Connection

When Eccentricity Becomes Diagnosis

In nineteenth-century England, a commission de lunatico was a legal proceeding that could declare a person of unsound mind and transfer control of their property to relatives. It was open to abuse: eccentric behavior, unconventional spending, or a family fight over inheritance could all serve as grounds. The year after Mill published On Liberty, Wilkie Collins published his bestselling novel The Woman in White, where this procedure plays a central role. The novel’s success suggests Mill was not alone in worrying that social tools meant to protect people from genuine harm could be turned against the merely unconventional.

The worry did not end with the Victorians. Early psychoanalysis treated many forms of women’s sexuality as mental illness. The contemporary anti-psychiatry movement charges that psychiatry too readily medicates behavior that falls within the normal range of human functioning. In each case, the dynamic Mill describes returns in a new register: rather than moralizing about people who do “what nobody does,” we rationalize our discomfort with them by treating their unconventionality as a symptom of illness, something they cannot help.

The Progressive Principle

Mill’s case for individuality culminates in a sweeping claim about what makes human progress possible. The passage below distinguishes two ideals that are often conflated: the spirit of liberty and the spirit of improvement. The two can come apart. Improvement can be forced on an unwilling people, in which case liberty’s defenders may find themselves siding, at least for a time, with the opponents of progress. Mill argues that liberty is nonetheless the only reliable engine of improvement, because liberty multiplies the potential sources of social improvement. Where custom rules unchallenged, change may have no source. Where individuals are free, every person is a possible center of improvement.

Chapter 3, page 272 

The despotism of custom is everywhere the standing hindrance to human advancement, being in unceasing antagonism to that disposition to aim at something better than customary, which is called, according to circumstances, the spirit of liberty, or that of progress or improvement. The spirit of improvement is not always a spirit of liberty, for it may aim at forcing improvements on an unwilling people; and the spirit of liberty, in so far as it resists such attempts, may ally itself locally and temporarily with the opponents of improvement; but the only unfailing and permanent source of improvement is liberty, since by it there are as many possible independent centres of improvement as there are individuals. The progressive principle, however, in either shape, whether as the love of liberty or of improvement, is antagonistic to the sway of Custom, involving at least emancipation from that yoke; and the contest between the two constitutes the chief interest of the history of mankind.

 The final sentence frames the struggle between custom and the progressive principle as, for Mill, “the chief interest” of history. This makes On Liberty about something far more expansive than coercion in developed democracies. The contest afflicts every era and every society, including the reader’s, however distant her own may feel from Victorian mores.

Quotable

 
“The despotism of custom is everywhere the standing hindrance to human advancement…”

Mill’s target here is despotic custom, not custom as such. He has no quarrel with people who freely choose to live in traditional ways. The problem arises when custom is enforced, when people are pressured or compelled into traditional modes of life rather than freely choosing them. That despotism shuts down the experimentation and learning on which improvement depends.

Summary

By the end of Chapter 3, readers should be able to understand Mill’s own summary of On Liberty from his posthumously published Autobiography (1873). There he writes that the book is

Chapter 7, page 259

[A] kind of philosophic text-book of a single truth, which the changes progressively taking place in modern society tend to bring out into ever stronger relief: the importance, to man and society of a large variety in types of character, and of giving full freedom to human nature to expand itself in innumerable and conflicting directions.

Full freedom requires both freedom of discussion (Chapter 2) and freedom of action (Chapter 3), and it benefits individuals and society alike. It lets creative people exercise their higher capacities in forming their own plan of life, and it expands everyone else’s options for finding a form of life in which they can flourish. This is the “progressive principle” that drives social growth, dynamism, and material prosperity.

 

Mill’s observations about the forces opposing this progress remain pertinent. Unfamiliar things make us uncomfortable, and we lapse into rationalizing that discomfort in moral terms. Mill gives us powerful reasons to treat such instinctive moralizing with suspicion, and to leave people free to live as they wish, so long as their conduct does not harm others. People given this freedom will make mistakes. Mill’s thesis is that the goods of the process outweigh the bads: that it serves not only the experimenter’s own happiness, but society’s as well.

Want to Learn More?

Mill’s Collected Works in 33 volumes are available for free at the Online Library of Liberty. If you want to see how Mill develops the argument from Chapter 3, keep reading the rest of On Liberty, which can be found in Volume XVIII of the Collected Works, or from Project Gutenberg. Chapters 4 and 5 take up the limits of society’s authority over the individual and apply Mill’s principles to specific cases. Mill extends the same concern with individuality to the position of women in The Subjection of Women, and lays out the moral framework underlying On Liberty in Utilitarianism, which is also covered in the Philosophy Teaching Library entry Pleasure, Happiness, and the Moral Life. For a broader overview of Mill’s moral and political thought, see the entry on Mill’s Moral and Political Philosophy in the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.

Acknowledgements

Citations to John Stuart Mill are from The Collected Works of John Stuart Mill, in 33 Volumes, edited by John M. Robson, available for free at the Online Library of Liberty. All images were created using Midjourney.

Citation

Gjesdal, Adam. 2026. “Choosing For Yourself: John Stuart Mill’s On Liberty, Chapter 3.” The Philosophy Teaching Library. Edited by Robert Weston Siscoe, <https://thephilosophylibrary.org/article/choosing-for-yourself/> 

Key Concept

Undisturbedness – Sextus says that the skeptic’s goal is “undisturbedness” (ataraxia), which we can think of as something like relief from anxiety. Pyrrhonists identify dogmatic beliefs about the way the world really is, as well as anxiety about the world not living up to these beliefs, as a main source of this disturbance.

Key Concept

Eccentricity – A trait closely related to genius: a disregard for social conventions and the pressures for social conformity. People may be legally free to engage in experiments in living, in the sense that no laws prohibit them. Yet external pressures to meet social expectations, along with internal desires to conform, may prevent them from doing so. Experiments in living thus require people who combine genius with eccentricity.

Key Concept

Genius – An individual with a great deal of imagination and the motivation to act on it. For Mill, genius is not limited to scientific or artistic genius; it also extends to the kind of person who imagines genuinely new ways of doing things that are not socially accepted. In doing so, they engage in an experiment in living. Importantly, this genius does not force their way of life onto others: they respect others’ freedom to live as they choose. So, Mill’s defense of genius would not apply to violent political revolutionaries.

Key Concept

Experiment in Living – A new way of living that isn’t yet socially accepted. Just as scientific experiments provide evidence that a specific hypothesis is true or false, experiments in living provide evidence that some novel kind of activity does or does not contribute to human happiness. The idea is very broad, covering ways of arranging society as well as ways of arranging an individual’s life, including one’s romantic life, career, or leisure activities. Establishing a socialist commune, raising a family as a gay couple, or being one of the first women to attend university are all examples.

Key Concept

Suspension of Judgment – We suspend judgment when we refrain from judging whether a statement is either true or false. In everyday speech, we might instead say something like “I don’t know,” or “I’m not sure.” We can also just shrug!

Key Concept

Enfant Terrible – A person whose unconventional or controversial behavior or ideas shock, embarrass, or annoy others.

Key Concept

Dr. Fridtjof Nansen (1861-1930) was a renowned scientist, explorer, and humanitarian famous in part for his Arctic explorations.

Key Concept

Mohammedan – an archaic, Western name for Muslims, or followers of the prophet Muhammad. The term is sometimes considered offensive for suggesting that Muslims worship Muhammad rather than God.

Key Concept

Theosophy – a religious movement that originated in the United States in the 19th century, theosophists sought to uncover the essential truths that underlie all the great world religions. 

Key Concept

Dead Hypothesis – an impossibility for our belief; one that does not tempt our will. 

Key Concept

Live Hypothesis – a real possibility for our belief; one that tempts our will.

Key Concept

Hypothesis – anything that may be proposed to our belief. 

Key Concept

Genuine Option – an option that is living (where both hypotheses are live), forced (where there is no third way out), and momentous (where the option has serious consequences).

Key Concept

Epistemic Certainty – a type of certainty about a belief that is fully supported by the evidence, so much so that the belief is guaranteed to be true. For example, knowing that 1 + 1= 2 is epistemically certain, because once you understand the terms of the equation, it is evident that it must be true.

Key Concept

Psychological Certainty – a type of certainty about a belief based on one’s subjective feeling of conviction, whether or not it’s true. For example, you might feel sure you saw a ghost, but that feeling alone doesn’t guarantee it happened — unlike epistemic certainty, such as knowing 1 + 1 = 2, which is guaranteed by the strength of your evidence.

Key Concept

Mystical Experience – a profound experience of the divine which brings one into a sense of union with God.

Key Concept

A Sufi refers to a practitioner of Sufism (tasawwuf), often known as the mystical tradition of Islam. Sufism is centered on forms of religious and ascetic practices which aim to achieve a spiritual state of purity and closeness to God.

Key Concept

Global Skepticism – the position that we do not know anything at all, so we should be skeptical of all knowledge claims.

Key Concept

Substance (Greek ousia) – the most fundamental sort of being in Aristotle’s ontology. Substances correspond roughly to what we would commonsensically treat as objects, like Secretariat the horse and Methuselah the redwood tree, as opposed to attributes of objects, like the greenness of Methuselah’s leaves, or collections of objects, like heaps of sand.

Key Concept

Hylomorphism – the view that objects are composed of matter (Greek hylē) and form (Greek morphē).

Key Concept

Privation (Greek sterēsis) – in Aristotle’s account of change, the underlier’s state of lacking the form that it will acquire in the change. Thus, when Socrates becomes musical, he starts out being unmusical, that is, lacking musicality, and this lack is the privation.

Key Concept

Form (Greek eidos) – the feature that, in Aristotle’s account of change, is acquired by the underlier in the process of the change (also called “shape” (Greek morphē)). For instance, when Socrates becomes musical, the musical (or musicality) is the form.ower in order to achieve peace and security.

Key Concept

Substantial Change – change with respect to an object’s essence, that is, with respect to what the object is. As a result of substantial change, objects go in and out of existence. For instance, when Socrates is killed, this is a substantial change.

Key Concept

Accidental Change –  change with respect to accidents. Accidents are features of an object that are not essential, i.e., do not pertain to what the object is. For instance, if Socrates becomes pale, he undergoes an accidental change, because pallor is an accident of Socrates. It is an accident because Socrates is a human being and being pale is no part of being a human being.

Key Concept

Underlier (Greek hypokeimenon) – in Aristotle’s account of change, what remains constant throughout the change and by which form is acquired and privation is lost. For instance, if Socrates becomes musical from being unmusical, Socrates is the underlier. (N.B. This same Greek term is also, especially in logical and metaphysical contexts, often translated as “subject”.)

Key Concept

Principle (Greek archē) – a starting point; in particular, something that we start from when explaining the world.

Key Concept

Social Contract – The agreement to give up certain freedoms and submit to a sovereign power in order to achieve peace and security.

Key Concept

War of All Against All – Hobbes’s description of the inevitable conflict in the state of nature.

Key Concept

Diffidence (Distrust) – Because we are equal, we compete for the same resources, which leads us to fear and suspect one another.

Key Concept

State of Nature – The condition where no common authority exists to enforce rules or laws.

Key Concept

Equality of Ability – Humans are roughly equal in their capacity to harm one another, even if some are stronger or smarter.

Key Concept

A disciple of Socrates. Both Plato and Xenophon represent him as emotional.

Key Concept

The vice of excessive pride (often towards the gods).

Key Concept

The Delphic Oracle was a high priestess at the temple of Delphi who delivered prophecies (often believed to come from Apollo himself).

Key Concept

Meletus was one of Socrates three accusers. Unfortunately, a record of Meletus’s speech did not survive.

Key Concept

Critias was an Athenian political leader and became the leader of the Thirty Tyrants, who violently ruled Athens after the end of the Peloponnesian War. He was well known for his intemperance and violence.

Key Concept

Alcibiades was an Athenian general who, after leading a disastrous expedition to Sicily, was exiled from Athens. He changed allegiances three times during the course of the Peloponnesian war and was well known for his treachery.

Key Concept

The famous Peloponnesian war (431 -404BCE) saw Athens defeated by Sparta, leading to the overthrowing of its democracy and a short rule (404-403 BCE) by the “Thirty Tyrants”. This group engaged in politically motivated executions and purges, but were themselves overthrown in 403BCE.

Key Concept

Virtue – A type of practical knowledge that takes the form of morally excellent habits or character traits. Examples of virtues are justice, piety, and courage. On the Socratic picture (i.e. Socrates’s philosophy), virtue is necessary (and perhaps even sufficient) for living a good life.

Key Concept

Socrates’s Daimonion – A divine sign that Socrates believed interfered whenever he was about to do something wrong. Socrates says this divine revelation comes by means of a voice. This is best understood as Socrates hearing something like “stop”, whenever he is about to go astray.

Key Concept

Lofty Utterances (Megalegoria) – Literally, “big talk”. Socrates is represented as speaking in a grand and unapologetic manner that antagonized the jurors. Much of Xenophon’s Apology takes up the question of whether these lofty utterances were foolish.

Key Concept

We don’t know much about Hermogenes. Nevertheless, both Plato and Xenophon portray him as being part of Socrates’s inner circle.

Key Concept

Apology (apologia) – Literally, “a speech in defense”. Rather than merely expressing regret – for instance, saying “I’m sorry” – an apologia in ancient Athens was a response to legal charges, usually in the courtroom.

Key Concept

Constant Conjunction – the observation that some things always occur together, either at the same time or one after another. For instance, there is a correlation, a consistent joint occurrence, between lightning and thunder. As another example, there is a constant conjunction of the heart ceasing to function and the body decaying.

Key Concept

A Priori Reasoning – drawing a conclusion based on relations between ideas, which have strict definitions, rather than drawing conclusions based on our personal experiences. For instance, we can conclude that each circle has only one radius length, which is the distance from any edge of the circle to its center point. We can reason to this conclusion without any personal experience, given that we understand the meaning of the word “radius”, the meaning of the word “center point”, and the meaning of the word “circle”.

Key Concept

Fun Fact – This passage foreshadows Kant’s groundbreaking claim that mathematical truths are knowable through mere operations of thought, but that they are not learned merely by learning the meaning of the relevant mathematical concepts. Euclid, for instance, demonstrated certain relations between angles and sides of triangles, but in doing so he went beyond the mere meaning of “angle” and “side” and “triangle”. Kant thus expands on Hume’s description here, arguing that some relations of ideas are not merely definitions of terms.

Key Concept

Matters of Fact – these are claims about the world that we learn by observation and experience. For example, we have to use telescopes or rovers to discover whether the moon has any water on it or not; we can’t just come to know that the moon has water on it by thinking about the moon clearly.

Key Concept

Relations of Ideas – these are claims we come to believe without any sensory experience required. For instance, we can come to realize that a circle has a perfect center point without discovering any perfect circles in the world. All we need to do is think clearly about what it means to be a circle!

Key Concept

Human Reason – the faculties/operations of the mind that allow us to draw conclusions from existing information. Hume takes there to be two sorts—demonstrative reasoning, which generates conclusions we can be certain of, and probabilistic reasoning, which suggests conclusions or shows them to be likely without guaranteeing that they are true.    

Key Concept

Induction – this is the process of observing the world, gaining knowledge via perception, and then drawing conclusions about unobserved aspects of the world. For instance, one might observe that all the Granny Smith apples one has ever tasted have been tart and conclude that all Granny Smith apples are, have been, and will be tart.

Key Concept

Kant’s line of thought is reminiscent of an objection to a liberal notion of freedom that has been discussed in political philosophy since Plato’s Republic. According to this objection, an unlimited and uncritical right to say and do what one wishes will lead to the neglect of the common good and ultimately to despotism. In what follows, Kant uses the metaphor of a kernel in order to demonstrate that the freedom of the people can only evolve in a peaceful environment. In order to grant such a peaceful environment, a disciplined private use of reason is necessary and, at times, also an army.

Key Concept

For Kant, a republic is a form of state in which the constitution guarantees that the laws that prevail are those that people (as free and equal citizens) give to themselves. According to him, the separation of powers is an indispensable institutional feature of republican states. With an absolute monarchy, by contrast, a single person reigns over the country. Frederick the Great was such an absolute sovereign, but in Kant’s view, also an enlightened one.

Key Concept

For Kant, “religious matters” were of particular importance as religion had a major influence on people’s private lives and on politics. Kant himself, however, advocated the ideals of religious tolerance and individual freedom as well as the separation of church and state.

Key Concept

Private Use of One’s Own Reason – The use of one’s reason in a professional or civic post or office — as a teacher, nurse, or a postal clerk.

Key Concept

Public Use of One’s Own Reason – The use of one’s reason as a scholar in exchange with the reading public through which the rules and principles of institutions and governments are critically examined.

Key Concept

Here, Kant refers to Frederick the Great (Friedrich II, 1712-1786), who was King of Prussia. A supporter of the Enlightenment, Frederick endorsed social and political change by abolishing torture and expanding the educational sector. He suspended censorship for newspapers with the exception of political content. Supporting freedom of religion in general, he nevertheless favored protestants for political higher office and did not grant Jews civil rights.

Key Concept

Prejudice – According to Kant, a prejudice in the sense of “preconception” is not by itself problematic. Preconceptions become prejudices in the negative sense when they are never called into question or when they are generalized inappropriately. Take, for example, the statement “Physical exercise is healthy!” While generally correct, this might not be true for people who are currently sick.

Key Concept

Freedom – A condition of enlightenment which refers to the ability and right to discuss controversial topics and to justify one’s own point of view. 

Key Concept

Public – With the German word “Publikum” Kant is thinking of the “reading public”, a group of people that can read and write and exchanges their thoughts through publications. At Kant’s time, publications appeared mostly in periodicals and books, which were accessible to a limited number of well-educated and wealthy people, most of them men.

Key Concept

Fair – In this context, the term ‘fair’ is another word for “beautiful” and “good-looking”. In the 18th century, women were generally characterized as the fair or fairer sex. The corresponding German phrase, “das schöne Geschlecht”, has a counterpart for men, which can be translated as “the strong sex” (“das starke Geschlecht”). These terms are not common nowadays but gender-related clichés still prevail.

Key Concept

Understanding – A conceptual faculty that, together with our senses, structures our cognition of the sensible world. This faculty is also broadly construed as the ability to consider and give reasons.

Key Concept

Immaturity –  The inability to use one’s reason in a legal and a figurative sense. In the legal sense, immaturity is due to minority of age, being less than 21 years old. When Kant was writing, it also applied to the entire female sex regardless of age. In both cases, fathers, brothers, and husbands served as guardians. In the figurative sense, immaturity can be self-imposed or imposed by others, and it can be overcome by enlightenment. 

Key Concept

Enlightenment – In German, ‘Aufklärung’ refers to a historical period (17th and 18th) as well as to a process of intellectual and institutional progress in individuals and institutions. Central ideals of this period were an emphasis on scientific knowledge, reason, and individual rights in contrast to superstition, authority, and tyranny. 

Key Concept

Every Vote Counts – The idea that “every vote counts” is informed by the normative standard that each person’s vote ought to have the same weight and the same power to determine election outcomes. Systems of representative democracy make this power uneven, however, with votes in large and/or homogeneous districts having proportionally less influence than votes in small and/or heterogeneous districts and votes in politically homogeneous districts.

Key Concept

The Divine Right of Kings – The theory that kings are chosen by God and thus that political revolt is a rebellion against the will of God.

Key Concept

Monarchy – A monarchy is a state where political deliberation is performed by one person (generally a king or queen).

Key Concept

Phalaris (c. 570-549 BCE) was, by most accounts, the very opposite of Cyrus, and he was used as an example of tyrannical cruelty in antiquity. He was tyrant of Acragas (now Agrigento) in Sicily. Diodorus Siculus records an infamous account of Phalaris’s torturing his enemies in a bronze bull placed over a roaring fire.

Key Concept

Cyrus the Great (d. 530 BCE) was the first emperor of the Persian Empire and a commonly used exemplar of the “enlightened monarch” in antiquity. He was renowned for his tolerance and care for his subjects. Xenophon, a student of Socrates, wrote a partly fictionalized biography of Cyrus called The Education of Cyrus (Cyropaedia). Peter Drucker, an influential 20th-century management theorist, called the Cyropaedia the best book on leadership.

Key Concept

Republic (res publica) – Cicero’s short definition of res publica is res populi (the ‘people’s thing’). Later in the Republic, Cicero famously defines a republic (1.39) as an assemblage of people associated with each other by consensus on justice (ius) and mutual benefit (utilitas).

Key Concept

Scipio Aemilianus Africanus was a hero among many Romans, but his reputation today is far less straightforward. Scipio Aemilianus led a Roman military campaign resulting in the utter destruction of the city of Carthage in 146 BCE. The Carthaginians were a prosperous Phoenician people in North Africa and rivals to Roman power. It has been argued that this act of ‘national extermination’ meets the modern definition of genocide. How should this knowledge impact how we view Scipio’s political philosophy expressed here?

Key Concept

This famous phrase, known by the abbreviation SPQR (senatus populusque Romanus), served as something like the official title of the Roman state (compare ‘USA’, ‘USSR’, ‘UK’), and encapsulated the ideal of a res publica (common property in public hands shared between the people and a council of elders).

Key Concept

Contemplation: The activity of human beings’ rationality. Contemplation is more than just thinking; it’s thinking excellently about ultimate truths. Contemplation is the ultimate activity associated with human flourishing.

Key Concept

Eudaimonia: Often translated as ‘happiness’ (in this text) or ‘flourishing’, eudaimonia is the activity of living the best possible life for a human being. Eudaimonia is more than just feeling happy or contented – it’s the idea that there is a best way to live for human beings.

Key Concept

Virtue: Virtues are cultivated tendencies to perform our function excellently, which allow us to reliably do the right thing, to the right extent, for the right reasons, given the demands of a specific circumstance. There are three components of virtues: virtues involve (a) skillful activity – they’re excellences after all!, (b) proper motivation, and (c) appropriate judgment – they often lead to judgments about what is the right thing to do, which requires careful attention to the circumstances.

Key Concept

Pleasure: The enjoyable feeling that accompanies some activities. Some philosophers (but not Aristotle!) think that pleasure is the only thing that is good in itself

Key Concept

Endoxic Method: An argumentative structure that begins by laying out the endoxa, or the beliefs of the many or the wise, then raises apparent problems for those views and develops a resolution to those problems.

Key Concept

The Problem of Induction: A problem for reasoning about the future based on past experiences. How can we be justified in believing that patterns of events in the past will continue into the future?

Key Concept

A Priori: Hume is using the term ‘a priori’ to denote the kind of reasoning that allows one to gain knowledge as relations of ideas—in other words, reasoning from one necessary, definitional truth to another.

Key Concept

Justification: the concept of justifying one’s thinking, or one’s beliefs, is important in epistemology. Roughly, one’s thinking or belief is justified when there is good reason for it, or when it is well supported or well evidenced. All of these are ways of referring to some connection between what we think or believe and what is, or to some way of at least making ourselves think that we are closer to the truth.

Key Concept

Inference: The psychological process of moving from one thought to another, such as moving from the thought “it’s raining, and I don’t want to get wet” to “I should get my umbrella”, or from “I am tired, and it’s getting late” to “I should get some sleep”. Nowadays, philosophers tend to use the term ‘inference’ to mean the same as ‘reasoning’, and tend instead to use the term ‘association’ to refer to movements between thoughts that are not based on any logic or evidence.

Key Concept

Matters of Fact: Knowledge that is gained by experience, such as by observing or experimenting with objects in the world. For example, knowing whether all swans in the world are white requires somebody to examine the many swans in the world and make sure they do not happen to discover a black one (and in fact, there are black swans!).

Key Concept

Relations of Ideas: Knowledge that is gained just by sufficiently clear thinking, without having to observe or experiment with objects in the world. For example, knowing that a triangle has three sides is something you can know just because of what it means to be a triangle, hence without having to carefully examine triangular objects that you find throughout the world.

Key Concept

Reasoning: Developing arguments to try and support the truth of one’s beliefs.

Key Concept

Causation: A relation between events, where one event (cause) is responsible for another (effect). Eating too much chocolate can cause the effect of having an upset stomach, and not getting enough sleep can cause someone to be grumpy.

Key Concept

Epistemological Theories: Theories about the nature and possibility of knowledge – whether, when, how, and to what extent we can know about reality, such as the physical world, or our own consciousness. For example, one epistemological theory says that we can gain understanding of our own consciousness by studying the brain, whereas other theories say that we can only gain knowledge of consciousness by reflecting on our own inner experiences. 

Key Concept

Aristotle means “happy” in the sense of a person who has developed a complete character, lived a full life, and become a true example of human goodness.

Key Concept

Happy Person – Someone who has developed her entire self well and lived a complete and flourishing life. She is a real and positive example of how we should live.

Key Concept

This is where Aristotle defines virtuous friends. These are friends who you actually answer the phone for. These are the friends who you ask for advice on work, love, and life. They are the friends that celebrate you for being you, but they also tell you when you’re messing things up. Not only do they love you, but you love them and try to be the same kind of friend to them too.

Key Concept

This is where Aristotle defines pleasurable friends. These are your TikTok, Snap Chat, or Instagram friends, the ones you post to social media when you’re having a good time.

Key Concept

This is Aristotle’s explicit definition of useful friends. These are your LinkedIn friends, those who you like networking with at events or enjoy working with on projects.

Key Concept

Virtuous Friendship – A friendship where people set as their goal for their friendship becoming good people together and living happy lives just because they value the good of their friends as persons. These are also known as “perfect” or “true” friendships. They are usually between people who are equally good. And they might be limited to people of equal social status, wealth, and power. Aristotle doesn’t think that any happy person will lack virtuous friends. But he thinks it’s likely that we’ll only have a few of this sort.

Key Concept

Pleasurable Friendship – A friendship where people set as their goal for their friendship some pleasant goal, such as friendship between people who go out on the town together. These friendships are plentiful and easy to form and dissolve.

Key Concept

Useful Friendship – A friendship where two people set as their goal for their friendship some useful or utilitarian purpose, such as friendship between work colleagues. These friendships are plentiful and easy to form and dissolve.

Key Concept

Aristotle uses “friend” broadly for any relationship between people who like each other, wish good things for each other, and get something out of spending time together.

Key Concept

Friendship – A relationship between two people who like each other, generally wish each other well, and have a goal for their interactions.

Key Concept

Happiness – The final end and highest good of human life. The perfect good that objectively fulfills human nature and subjectively satisfies desire. 

Key Concept

Happiness Criteria – The conditions that the true object of happiness must satisfy. They are: finality, intrinsic value, purity, internality, authenticity, stability, self-sufficiency, completeness.

Key Concept

Object of Happiness – The thing in which happiness essentially consists, the attainment of which will make us truly happy.

Key Concept

Highest Good – The greatest good for a human being.

Key Concept

Final End – The ultimate goal of human life. All of our other goals are chosen for the sake of this final end.

Key Concept

Constituent Principles – Parts of a material object that cause the object to be the sort of thing that it is, but that cannot be removed from that object (in the way that some properties can be gained or lost). For Aquinas, this would include things such as form (the structure of a material object) and matter (that which is structured). For example, Dylan’s form is his soul, and his matter is his body. His soul and body are distinct, but Dylan could not exist if he were not composed of both.

Key Concept

Accident/accidental property – A property that something can possess or not possess while still remaining the thing that it is. For example, Dylan could grow taller, or he could stop being musical, without becoming a different person. By contrast, rationality is an essential property of Dylan, since being rational is part of the “what it is to be” of a human being.

Key Concept

Subject/Suppositum – Something or someone that can bear properties but is not itself a property that something else can bear. Dylan can have properties, like being short or being musical, but no one can have Dylan as a property.

Key Concept

Property – A feature that an object has. For example, a ball could be orange, which means that the ball has the property of orangeness. In many cases a property can be gained or lost. The ball could be painted green, in which case it would gain the property of greenness and lose the property of orangeness.

Key Concept

Actuality – The being, or act of being, of a thing. For example, hot water is actually hot (the water is hot), even though it is potentially cold. Likewise, a boy is actually a human being (he is a human being), even though he is also potentially a full-grown man (and he will still be an actual human being when he becomes a full-grown man).

Key Concept

Potentiality – Ways a given thing can become different from the way it is now. For example, cold water is potentially hot, since it can be heated up, and an acorn is potentially an Oak tree since it can grow to full size under the right conditions.

Key Concept

Essence – The “what it is to be” of a thing. For example, the essence of a human being is to be a rational animal, and the essence of a cheetah is to be the fastest land animal.

Key Concept

Principle of Specialization – The idea that work is more efficient and more effective if each worker specializes in exactly one task.

Key Concept

Extrinsic Value – Value a thing has that is dependent on something else. Extrinsically valuable things are worth pursuing because they get you something else that is valuable. Money, for instance, is only useful because it can be exchanged for other things.

Key Concept

Intrinsic Value – Value a thing has independently or inherently. Intrinsically valuable things are worth pursuing for their own sake.

Key Concept

Adeimantus and Glaucon were Plato’s older brothers (along with an older sister, Potone). They were both honored for military valor at a battle with Megara. We know little about their lives otherwise. Potone had a son, Speusippus, who inherited leadership of the Academy upon Plato’s death.

Key Concept

Thrasymachus was a real person, who lived about 459-400 BCE moved to Athens from Chalcedon to become a sophist (a professional teacher and public speaker). Only a few fragments of his work survives

Key Concept

Prudence – Prudence is virtue wherein a person is able to choose, in any given situation, the course of action that will lead to greater happiness. For example, a prudential person knows when it is appropriate to continue a difficult conversation and when it is best to wait for a more appropriate time.

Key Concept

Pleasure – Epicurus would have us think about pleasure as coming in two forms: moving and static. Moving pleasures are the type that we experience in the process of satisfying a desire (this coffee tastes amazing!). Static pleasure is the feeling of being satisfied — no longer experiencing need or want (I am feeling so peaceful sitting in the park). Epicurus thinks these static pleasures are the best sort.

Key Concept

Epicurus believed that reality  is composed of matter. This sets him apart from other philosophers of the time who, often influenced by Plato, believed that reality is composed of both the material and immaterial (like the soul, or the Platonic forms).

Key Concept

Happiness – Epicurus uses the Greek word “eudaimonia,” which is typically translated into English as “happiness.” Whereas today happiness is most often used to describe a momentary feeling (this new notebook makes me happy!) Epicurus means something more like a consistent state of well-being and contentment.

Key Concept

Unconditioned: an ultimate explanation of reality. For example, if I explain why it is raining today by appealing to some atmospheric conditions, I can always ask for the cause of those conditions, and so on. Only a cause that is not caused by anything else (something unconditioned) would give us an ultimate explanation.

Key Concept

Transcendental Idealism: Kant’s mature philosophical position. It holds that appearances are not things in themselves, but representations of our mind. It is opposed to transcendental realism, which identifies appearances with things in themselves.

Key Concept

Appearances (vs. things in themselves): things as they are experienced by us (also known as phenomena). They should be distinguished from things as they are independently of our experience (things in themselves or noumena).

Key Concept

Metaphysics: the study of what there is. Traditionally, metaphysics is divided into general metaphysics and special metaphysics. The former investigates the general features of reality and asks questions such as ‘What is possible?’. The latter studies particular kinds of being and asks questions such as ‘Does God exist?’ or ‘Is the soul immortal?’.

Key Concept

Reason: the faculty that knows a priori. Kant uses this term in a general sense (the knowing faculty as such) and in a specific sense (the faculty that demands ultimate explanations).

Key Concept

A priori: term denoting propositions that can be known independently from experience. For example, propositions such as ‘All bachelors are unmarried’ or ‘The whole is greater than its parts’ can be known without recourse to any experience.

Key Concept

Make sure not to think that ‘unjustified’ means ‘false.’ Even if they are true, the point is just that this would not be something that had been shown.

Key Concept

‘Absolute’ might be a confusing word, here. Socrates means that the geometers are not reasoning about their drawing of the square, for example, but of the square itself. They do not conclude that, for the square they drew, the area is equal to the square of a side – they conclude that this is true for squares as an intelligible object, or, as Plato would say, the Form of the square.

Key Concept

By ‘science’, Plato means to be talking about all rational disciplines, including mathematics.

Key Concept

The form of the beautiful has to be perfectly beautiful because all instances of beautiful things are explained by it, so it has to be responsible for the highest possible degrees of beauty possessed by anything. Moreover, it has no trace of ugliness in it.

Key Concept

The form of the beautiful has to be immaterial because all the many beautiful things do not share any material – that is, they are all made of different stuff.

Key Concept

Form (εἶδος / ἰδέα) – Intelligible, immaterial, perfect entities that explain the unity among the many things which share the feature named by the entity (e.g., Beauty, Squareness, Oddness). For example, think of a square. There might be many different squares, but they all share features like having four sides of equal length. So, the Form of Squareness would include all of those features that make something a square.

Key Concept

Guardian – This is the name Plato gives to the ruling class in his ideal city. Think of them as philosopher kings – they have complete control over the organization of the state. The Republic is partially about why Plato thinks they would be needed for an ideal system of government and what they would need to learn to do the job well.

Key Concept

Plato has previously argued that we are made up of different parts. The first part is the appetitive which is responsible for our desires for food, sex, and other bodily needs. Then there is the spirited part, which longs for fame and honor. Finally, he identifies the rational part, which discerns what is good and bad for us through reason. The parts can all come into conflict with one another, and managing their relations is what Plato thinks justice is all about.

Key Concept

Soul (ψῡχή) – What Greeks meant by this word is controversial. For now, think of it as the thing that makes you different from a rock or other objects, the thinking and experiencing part of you as well as the part of you that acts and makes decision. You might use the word ‘mind’ or ‘self’ to talk about this.

Key Concept

Virtue – Virtues are the character traits that make a person good. For example, most people consider courage and generosity to be virtues. English-speakers usually reserve the word ‘virtue’ for human beings, but in ancient Greek the word can be more comfortably applied to other beings as well.

Key Concept

Was it his burly physique, his wide breadth of wisdom, or his remarkable forehead which earned him this nickname?

Key Concept

Aporia – A Greek term for “being at a loss” or “clueless.” Socrates often questions people until they have no idea how to define something that they thought they understood.

Key Concept

You might be confused by the word ‘attention’ below. In Greek the word is therapeia, from which we get the English word ‘therapy.’ It primarily means the same as ‘service’ as in ‘to serve,’ but shades into ‘worship,’ ‘take care of,’ and ‘attend to.’

Key Concept

Meletus – A poet and citizen of Athens and one of Socrates’ accusers. Amongst other things, Meletus accused Socrates of impiety and corrupting the youth.

Key Concept

Divine Voluntarism – The idea that God is free to determine even the most basic truths. If divine voluntarism is true, then God could have made it so that 2+2=5 or so that cruelty and blasphemy are holy and good.

Key Concept

Euthyphro Dilemma – The question, “Is a thing holy because the gods love it, or do the gods love it because it is holy?” The general idea of a forced choice (or “dilemma”) about the true order of explanation occurs often in philosophy and gets referred to by this term.

Key Concept

Essence – What a thing fundamentally is. A square might be red or blue without changing the fact that it’s a square, but a square must have four sides, so having four sides is part of a square’s essence.

Key Concept

Definition – The perfect description of a thing. A definition should pick out all and only examples of a thing. For example, ‘bachelor’ might be defined as ‘unmarried man,’ because all unmarried men are bachelors, and only unmarried men are bachelors.

Key Concept

In Disney’s retelling of the Hunchback of Notre Dame, the clergyman Claude Frollo orders the death of many Roma on religious grounds. It is clear, however, that he is really motivated by spite and his unrequited lust for the Romani woman Esmerelda.

Key Concept

Spanish conquistadors were shocked by the scope of ritual human sacrifice among the Aztecs, as hundreds or even thousands of people were sacrificed each year. The Aztecs thought that the sacrifices could repay the sacrifices the gods had made in creating the sun and earth.

Key Concept

Zeus – The god of sky and thunder in ancient Greek mythology, Zeus was depicted as chief among the gods and called the father of the gods and men.

Key Concept

Forms – The perfect, divine, and intelligible entities that exist independently of the physical world. They are comprehensible only through reason, not through our senses, and their existence explains the properties of objects in the physical world.

Key Concept

Recollection – The soul existed prior to birth; during this time it learned everything, and hence all learning is only recalling what we already know.

Key Concept

Immortality of the Soul – Unlike the body, the soul is not subject to physical death, because it is immortal and indestructible.

Key Concept

Philosophy – The practice of preparing the soul for death by training it to think and exist independently of the body

Key Concept

Death – Plato understands this as the soul’s separation from the body

Key Concept

Human Identity Across Time – Locke’s notion that any human stays the same across time if, and only if, it maintains the same (distinctively human) organizing structure of parts.

Key Concept

Substance Identity Across Time – Something is the same substance across a segment of time if, and only if, it continuously exists across the relevant segment of time without gaining or losing any of its parts.

Key Concept

Immaterial Soul – A personal thinking substance without any physical constitution.

Key Concept

Personal Identity Across Time – Whatever makes someone the numerically same person (i.e., that very person) at different times; according to Locke, it is a relation of first-person consciousness via memory.

Key Concept

Person – Locke’s forensic definition of person (pertaining to courts of law regarding the justice of praise, blame, reward, or punishment): a thinking, intelligent being, that has reason and reflection, and can consider itself as itself, the same thinking thing in different times and places.

Key Concept

The Prophet Muhammad is a central figure in Islam.  He is viewed as the last of a long line of prophets, which includes Moses and Jesus. He is responsible for writing the Quran, which was dedicated to him by the angel Gabriel.  His life and sayings are recounted in the Hadith; he is viewed as an exemplary role model of Islamic life and faith.

Key Concept

Exhortation — The method of understanding and interpreting Truth available to the common people. The majority of people take scripture literally and understand truth and right action based upon this understanding. They are persuaded by the vivid imagery of the Quran and the rhetorical exhortations of religious leaders. Averroes takes this to be lowest form of understanding

Key Concept

Dogmatic Discourse — The method of understanding displayed by those who, through natural ability and habit, are able to have a deeper understanding of the Quran, and of the truths it illuminates. These people know that not all of the scriptures are to be taken literally, and that greater underlying Truths are revealed by interpreting some elements allegorically. Still, they err on the side of dogmatism and literal interpretation whenever uncertainty arises. Averroes associates this way of thinking with Muslim theologians and views this to be the middle level of understanding.     

Key Concept

Philosophical Inference – The type of understanding associated with philosophical demonstration or argument. This is the highest level of understanding, accomplished by a select few, who have a natural capacity for philosophy and proper philosophical training. 

Key Concept

Law — The Quran (the central religious text of Islam) and, to a lesser extent, the Hadith (reports of what the prophet Muhammad said and did). Averroes is concerned with explaining how philosophy relates to what Muslims take to be the unerring Truth regarding God and the nature of existence, as they are expressed in Scripture.

Key Concept

Occasionalism — a theory claiming that God is the only true cause of changes in the world. For example, when you high-five me, you’re not really the cause of the stinging sensation I experience. God is the cause. Your high five is just the occasion on which God causes it.     

Key Concept

Interactionism — a theory claiming that things in the world can truly cause changes in each other. For example, when you high-five me, you truly cause me to experience a stinging sensation in my hand.

Key Concept

Substance Dualism — a theory claiming that the mind (or soul) and body are two distinct and very different things.

Key Concept

Body — what it sounds like! The body is the physical part or aspect of a thing and has characteristics like shape, size, etc.

Key Concept

Soul — that part or aspect of a thing involving mental aspects of their existence, e.g., thoughts, feelings, decisions, etc. The “soul”, in this sense, is more or less just the mind.

Key Concept

Causal Interaction — When one thing acts (i.e., itself does something) and in so acting makes another thing change. For example, when you high-five me, you cause me to experience a stinging sensation in my hand.

Key Concept

God as God – The phrase “God as God” is basically a synonym for “God the subject.” In other words, it refers to God precisely in God’s status as an incomprehensible divine Other.

Key Concept

Incarnation – The Christian doctrine of the incarnation is the notion that the word of God became fully human in the person of Jesus of Nazareth. It is closely associated with the doctrine of the trinity, which asserts that God the Father, God the Son (Jesus as the word made flesh), and God the Holy Spirit are one God.

Key Concept

Religious Fanaticism – In Feuerbach’s use of the term, a religious fanatic is someone who is unwaveringly faithful to God as an utterly mysterious superhuman being. They subordinate other things—especially the love of other humans—to submission before this divine other.

Key Concept

God the Subject – When Feuerbach refers to God as a subject, he is referring to the commonplace religious belief that God is a being who has various attributes, like a loving nature.

Key Concept

Faith Separates Man From God – Faith separates God from man in this sense: it treats God as a mysterious other, a being radically distinct from us.

Key Concept

 Faith – Belief in and fidelity to a transcendent divine subject like God.

Key Concept

Orthodoxy – Orthodoxy refers to “right belief,” and it is concern with identifying heresies and ensuring that people believe and practice correctly.

Key Concept

Indirect Form of Self-Knowledge – Feuerbach’s view is that religious belief is a naive way of relating to our human nature and its perfections. It is naive or childlike because it treats these as external realities that belong to God. He believes a mature and contemplative person realizes these don’t belong to God, but rather to our species, abstractly conceived.

Key Concept

Above the Individual Man – The human perfections are “above the individual” insofar as no particular individual ever perfectly realizes them. They are abstractions.

Key Concept

Divine Trinity – Feuerbach is having fun here. He is using the theological phrasing of the Trinity to talk about human perfections. In calling reason, love, and freedom of the will “divine,” he means they are absolutely good; they are activities whose goodness is intrinsic to their practice or exercise. This isn’t a novel philosophical view. For example, Immanuel Kant argued that autonomy or a good will is the only thing which is unconditionally good.

Key Concept

Perfections – The end to which a faculty or power is ordered. For example, omniscience would be the perfection of the intellect. Traditionally, God is said to possess all perfections.

Key Concept

Love – When Feuerbach writes about love, he is referring to unconditional concern for others and the desire for fellowship with them. He is here asserting that love, understood in this sense, is the perfect activity of the affective faculty. In other words, our feelings and passions are fully actualized and engaged in an intrinsically valuable activity when we genuinely love others.

Key Concept

Infinite – The infinite is whatever can be understood as unbounded or unlimited. Human nature in the abstract is unbounded and unlimited. It is only bounded or limited in its concrete form as it is realized by particular material individuals.

Key Concept

Higher Consciousness – The sort of consciousness that mature human beings possess, but which other animals do not. It is “higher” than animal consciousness because it involves thinking abstractly about the form or essence of things.

Key Concept

Science – Feuerbach uses the term science in its classical sense, meaning systematically organized knowledge. Any body of knowledge founded on an understanding of first principles and the essences of things is a science in this sense.

Key Concept

Popular Sovereignty – The view that a government’s authority to rule comes from the people, making a ruler subject to the will of their citizens.

Key Concept

The Divine Right of Kings – The theory that kings are chosen by God and thus that political revolt is a rebellion against the will of God.

Key Concept

Synthesis – The prefix ‘syn-’ means “together,” so a synthesis “brings together” or combines elements of both a thesis and its antithesis.

Key Concept

Antithesis– An antithesis is the contradiction of a thesis. For example, internationalism could be understood as the antithesis of nationalism.

Key Concept

Thesis – In Hegelian terms, a thesis can be understood as a position or theory. Examples include any of the “-isms” that we discuss in science, history, and philosophy, such as Darwinism, capitalism, nationalism, etc.

Key Concept

Progressor’s Temptation – a unique temptation for those making progress in which pride impedes their further progress and leads to backsliding.

Key Concept

Progressors – those who are not yet expert Stoic practitioners, but who are also aware of the fact that they must change their lives in that direction. They are working on making progress.

Key Concept

Intellectualism – the philosophical view that our motivations and emotions are all judgments. The reason why you do something, your motivation, is because you believe it’s the right thing to do. The reason why you feel good or bad about something, an emotion, is because you believe that something good or bad happened to you.

Key Concept

Duties – acts of service, obedience, and respect that we owe to each other. The duties we owe to each other depend on what kind of relationship we have.

Key Concept

Askeses – exercises of Stoic thought and practice that make the lessons and habits of Stoic philosophy second-nature for Stoic practitioners.

Key Concept

Externals – things that are not under our control but that are all-too-easily confused with things that should be important to us, like wealth, status, and pleasure. Too many people believe externals like these are necessary for the good life, and the Stoic path is to focus not on these things but rather what is up to us. 

Key Concept

The Fundamental Division – the division between things that are under our direct control and those that are not. The important lesson is to care only about the things we can control.

Key Concept

The Greatest Happiness Principle – A principle which says that actions are right insofar as they promote happiness and wrong insofar as they promote unhappiness

Key Concept

Higher and Lower Pleasures – Types of pleasures that differ in terms of their quality. Things like food and drugs create lower pleasures. Things like intellectual pursuits and doing the right thing create higher forms of pleasure.

Key Concept

The Doctrine of Swine – An objection that utilitarianism entails that if people would be happy rolling in mud, that’s what would be morally best for them to do, so we should reject the theory.

Key Concept

Utilitarianism – A normative theory of which actions are right or wrong. Utilitarianism says the right action is that which maximises utility.

Key Concept

Jeremy Bentham – Considered by some as the father of utilitarianism, Bentham was a moral philosopher and one of John Stuart Mill’s teachers

Key Concept

Epicurus – an ancient Greek philosopher and one of the first to advocate that the ultimate good is experiencing pleasure and avoiding pain.

Key Concept

Utility – The thing that is ultimately valuable in itself. For Mill, this is happiness, which he then understands as pleasure and the absence of pain.

Key Concept

Contract Theory – a modern political theory identifying consent as the sole justification for government. Contract theory is associated with Thomas Hobbes (1588-1679), John Locke (1632-1704), Jean Jacques Rousseau (1712-1778), and more recently, John Rawls (1921-2002)

Key Concept

Prejudice – a foundational, strongly held, unreasoned (but not necessarily irrational) moral opinion or belief. We might believe, for example, that parents have special obligations towards their own children.

Key Concept

A Priori – a philosophical term of art meaning (in Latin) “prior to experience,” which refers to knowledge that is innate or arrived at purely through reasoning, like the truths of mathematics.

Key Concept

Rights – moral claims invoking immunity from (or entitlement to) some specific treatment (or good) from others. Commonly recognized rights include the right to free speech or the right to healthcare. 

Key Concept

Reform – a change in the social order that originates from the existing character of society. An example would be market-based healthcare reform in a capitalist society.

Key Concept

Conservatism – a modern political ideology that aims to preserve and promote the existing (or traditional)  institutions of society. These institutions typically include the rule of law, property, the family, and religion. 

Key Concept

Contingent Being – A being that can fail to exist. Its existence is not guaranteed. This being might come to exist or it might not.

Key Concept

Necessary Being – A being that can’t fail to exist. Its non-existence is impossible. This also means that such a being has always existed.

Key Concept

Want to read more about why the infinite regress option doesn’t work in the Second Way? Check out Sean Floyd’s entry in the Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy.

Key Concept

Efficient Cause – An efficient cause is something that directly makes another thing exist or move. An example of this is when I kick a ball down a hill. I am the efficient cause of the ball rolling down the hill because I make it move down the hill.

Key Concept

Infinite Regress: Begin with some fact. We begin to explain that fact by appealing to another fact, where these facts are related by either causality or dependence. To create the regress, you keep appealing to more and more facts about causality and dependence without end.

Key Concept

Actuality – An ability or action something is currently exercising. Imagine that I am sitting comfortably at my desk, and then I stand up to take a break from reading. In this case, I am now actually standing. 

Key Concept

Potentiality – What something has the capacity to do, but isn’t currently doing. Imagine I am sitting comfortably at my desk. Even though I’m not currently standing, I have the capacity to be standing. So, even while I’m not standing, I have the potential to stand. 

Key Concept

Theists and Non-Theists – A theist is someone who believes that God exists, while a non-theist does not. Non-theists include atheists, who believe that God does not exist, and agnostics, who are uncertain about whether God exists.

Key Concept

Glaucon – one of Plato’s brothers and one of Socrates’ main interlocutors in the Republic dialogue. In that dialogue, he challenges Socrates to provide a compelling justification for why one should be a just person beyond merely following conventions or avoiding punishment. This sets up Socrates’ defense of justice as intrinsically worthwhile. Throughout the Republic, Glaucon prods Socrates to fully explain his theories of the ideal society, philosopher-kings, and the Form of the Good.

Key Concept

Aristotle – a Greek philosopher (384-322 BC) who studied under Plato and went on to be one of the most influential philosophers to ever live. Simply called “The Philosopher” by Thomas Aquinas and others in the medieval period, Aristotle’s views would eventually be synthesized with Christian theology, laying the intellectual foundation for later scholarly developments in Western Europe.

Key Concept

Understanding – Socrates describes education as turning one’s “understanding” in the right direction. The word “understanding” here translates the ancient Greek term “to phronēsai,” which means “understanding,” “being conscious,” or “having insight.” People who are wicked focus their “understanding” on how best to accomplish their selfish and narrow desires. Those who are wise, in contrast, have learned to focus their “understanding” on what is truly good and beneficial.

Key Concept

The Form of the Good – Socrates characterizes the ultimate goal of education as coming to know “the Form of the Good.” The Form of the Good is his technical term for the meaning of goodness: what it is to be good. Socrates is clear that this “knowledge of the Good” is not simply theoretical knowledge, but also knowledge in the sense of “knowing how”: knowing how to achieve what’s good, to do what’s good, to accomplish what’s good. Mere “book knowledge” or simply being smart is not enough.

Key Concept

The Intelligible – Socrates uses “the intelligible” to name the aspects of the world that we can only grasp through thinking or insight. With my eyes I can see the tree outside my window, but what it means to be a tree is something I can only comprehend in thought. Likewise, I can see the people around me, but human nature, human dignity, and what it means to be human is something I can only grasp conceptually. “The intelligible” is the world insofar as it “makes sense” and can be comprehended.

Key Concept

The Visible – By “the visible,” Socrates means those aspects of the world we can perceive with our five senses and our imagination—those aspects of the world we can see, hear, taste, smell, touch, and imagine. For example, with my eyes I can see the sky, trees, people around me, and so on as visible things. “The visible” is the world insofar as it can be perceived and imagined. 

Key Concept

Education – Socrates says that the allegorical story he tells represents the effect of education on human nature. “Education” here is a translation of the ancient Greek word “paideia,” which means “education” in the widest sense of the term. “Paideia” doesn’t mean “education” in the sense of going to school or getting good grades. Instead, it refers to the process of becoming a wise, intelligent, good, and well-rounded human being.

Key Concept

Allegory – An allegory is a symbolic narrative where characters, events, and/or settings represent abstract ideas or convey deeper meanings beyond the literal story. Socrates tells such a symbolic narrative in the passages below. The characters, events, and setting of his narrative symbolize the effect of what he calls “education.” 

Key Concept

Self-knowledge – Knowledge of the contents of one’s own mind, such as one’s own beliefs and desires. Self-knowledge can be gained through introspection, that is, by reflecting on what one thinks and experiences. Some philosophers believe that self-knowledge has special properties that our knowledge of the external world lacks, such as being clearer, more reliable, or more valuable.

Key Concept

Dualism – The view that the mind is entirely distinct from the body. This view is usually contrasted with different kinds of monism, which hold that the mind is ultimately just a part of the body (materialism) or that the body is ultimately just a part of the mind (idealism). Dualists hold that the mind and the body are fundamentally different aspects of reality, and both categories are needed to properly describe the universe, especially the human person. 

Key Concept

The Self – What the ‘I’ in ‘I am, I exist’ refers to; the part of you that really makes you you. Many philosophers have provided rich accounts of what the self ultimately is, including the soul, the mind, one special feature of the mind (such as consciousness), a mixture of all these elements, or perhaps a mere illusion.  

Key Concept

The ‘Cogito’ – Descartes’ famous claim ‘I think, therefore I am’ is often referred to as the cogito. The name comes from the Latin rendering of this phrase, which is ‘cogito, ergo sum.’ Descartes held that one can always believe this proposition with certainty. We cannot doubt our own existence, so the cogito survives his exercise of intense doubt. The cogito appears several times in Descartes’ writings, and he often phrased it slightly differently each time. It appears in the Second Meditation as ‘I am, I exist.’

Key Concept

Certainty – When one believes something with certainty, one is maximally confident that it is true. A certainty is something that is beyond dispute or immune to doubt. Although this captures the basic idea, like many epistemological notions, clarifying precisely what the notion of certainty amounts to is an ongoing area of philosophical research. 

Key Concept

Vice – A bad habit that we learn over time through instruction or instinct and that we develop through repetition. What makes the habit bad is that, once we have that habit, our tendency is to do the incorrect thing in certain types of situations. We may choose to do something entirely uncalled for in that situation, or we may act at the wrong time, in the wrong way, to the wrong degree, or with the wrong attitudes, or for the wrong reasons.

Key Concept

Relative Mean – The “Goldilocks amount” of some type of action or emotion. When you act in this way, according to Aristotle, you act exactly as is required under the current circumstances. This means that you do what is called for by the situation at hand, rather than doing something too extreme or not doing something extreme enough. You do something in the moderate amount (the mean amount) relative to the specific situation you are in when you need to act.

Key Concept

Excellence/Virtue – A good habit that we learn over time through instruction and repetition. What makes the habit good is that, once we have that habit, we have a strong tendency to do the right thing at the right time, in the right way, to the right degree, with the right attitudes, whenever we are confronted with a situation that we know calls us to exercise that habit.

Key Concept

Doxastic Voluntarism – the view that we have at least some control over what we believe.

Key Concept

Evidence – information that increases the probability that a claim is true.

Key Concept

Sufficient – enough of something for a particular purpose. Whether something is sufficient is context-dependent.

Key Concept

Solon – In the Histories of Herodotus, Solon visits Croesus, the king of Lydia. Even though Croesus shows Solon all of his wealth, Solon refuses to call him the happiest man who ever lived because he does not know how Croesus will die

Key Concept

Priam – According to Greek mythology, Priam was the final king of Troy during the Trojan War. Despite his wealth and political power, he was killed by Achilles’ son Neopotolemus during the Sack of Troy

Key Concept

Virtue – The consistent and reliable tendency to perform one’s function excellently. When a person has a certain virtue, like courage, they have spent time developing the habit, in this case reacting to danger well, using their human abilities. The virtues then make it possible for us to live a life of flourishing

Key Concept

Sardanapalus – An Assyrian king described by the historian Diodorus as living a life of extreme decadence. Sardanapalus indulged himself with food, alcohol, and many concubines, even going so far to say that physical gratification is the purpose of life. Chrysippus said that, on his tomb is inscribed the following: “Though knowing full well that thou art but mortal, indulge thy desire, find joy in thy feasts. Dead, thou shalt have no delight […] I have only what I have eaten, what wantonness I have committed, what joys I received through passion; but my many rich possessions are now utterly dissolved.”

Key Concept

Function – the characteristic activity of a given thing which makes it what it is. The function of a knife is cutting, while the function of a heart is to pump blood

Key Concept

Eudaimonia – Frequently translated as ‘happiness’, eudaimonia means the attainment of active human flourishing, and is the end Aristotle identifies as humanity’s highest final good

Key Concept

Final Good – A good that we pursue for its own sake. Common examples of final goods include happiness, knowledge, and friendship

Key Concept

Instrumental Good – A good that we pursue for the sake of some other good. A common example is money, as money allows us to purchase other kinds of goods

Key Concept

Anytus – an Athenian politician, war general, and  one of the primary accusers behind Socrates’ prosecution. Anytus feared that Socrates would undermine the young Athenian democracy he had helped create and defend

Key Concept

Oracle of Delphi – the high priestess at the temple at Delphi, the oracle was one of the most sought after seers of the ancient world and was thought to relay messages from the god Apollo

Key Concept

Chaerephon – an ancient Greek from the city Sphettus, Chaerephon is remembered as a loyal friend of Socrates, also making an appearance in two other Platonic dialogues, the Charmides and the Gorgias

Key Concept

Meletus – A poet and citizen of Athens and one of Socrates’ accusers. Amongst other things, Meletus accused Socrates of corrupting the youth

Key Concept

Apollo – the ancient sacred site Delphi was dedicated to the god Apollo, an ancient Greek god and the god that Socrates refers to throughout the Apology

Key Concept

Virtue – a character trait, acquired through habitual practice, that enables one to act well. The virtues can also be thought of as excellences of human character, as they make it possible for us to live a life of flourishing. Examples of the virtues include courage, prudence, and justice

Key Concept

The Evil Demon Argument – Argues that we cannot hold any of our beliefs with certainty because we could be radically deceived by an evil demon. A classic argument given by Descartes for doubting the reliability of almost all of our beliefs

Key Concept

Philosophical Skepticism – The position that we do not know many things that we ordinarily take ourselves to know

Key Concept

A Posteriori Knowledge – Knowledge that can only be acquired through having particular, concrete experiences. Such knowledge can be gained simply through our everyday experiences, or through more complex means like controlled scientific experiments

Key Concept

A Priori Knowledge – Knowledge that can be gained without having any particular concrete experiences. Such knowledge is typically gained by rational insight or intuition

Key Concept

Cartesian Method of Doubt – A process employed by René Descartes of rejecting all beliefs that he had at least some reason to doubt in order to see if he had any beliefs that he could know with certainty

Key Concept

Revelation – Theological truths that have been made known by means of some religious text, testimony, authority, or experience, or the act or process in which such truths are made known.

Key Concept

Rationalism – The view that the only reliable means of coming to know truths about God is reason. As a result, what we might otherwise believe by means of faith ought to be disregarded or even rejected in favor of what we must believe by means of reason.

Key Concept

Fideism – The view that the only reliable means of coming to know truths about God is faith. As a result, what we might otherwise believe by means of reason ought to be disregarded or even rejected in favor of what we must believe by means of faith.

Key Concept

Faith – The act of accepting a proposition as true for which there is less than demonstrable evidence, which rises above mere opinion but falls short of logical or scientific demonstration. Faith can also refer to a particular religious tradition or the body of beliefs that are central to that religious tradition.

Key Concept

Virtue – a character trait, acquired through habitual practice, that enables one to act well. The virtues can also be thought of as excellences of human character, as they make it possible for us to live a life of flourishing. Examples of the virtues include courage, prudence, and justice

Key Concept

Socratic Ignorance – an awareness of one’s own ignorance, and the reason that Socrates was deemed wise by the Oracle of Delphi. A person who lacks Socratic Ignorance may believe they know many things they actually don’t, leading them to overestimate how well they understand the world

Key Concept

Apology – a formal defense of justification of an action or belief. A Christian apologist, for example, is someone who defends their faith and seeks to justify it through an appeal to reason.

Historical Connection

Solon’s Warning

In the Histories of Herodotus, Solon visits Croesus, the king of Lydia. Even though Croesus shows Solon all of his wealth, Solon refuses to call him the happiest man who ever lived because he does not know how Croesus will die

Historical Connection

Priam

According to Greek mythology, Priam was the final king of Troy during the Trojan War. Despite his wealth and political power, he was killed by Achilles’ son Neopotolemus during the Sack of Troy